Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ben K's avatar

Hi Reiman!

I appreciate you sharing your thoughts in such depth, and I’m very interested in the journey you’re on as it relates to gender and wholeness. I’ll be honest. I’m pretty upset about some of what you wrote. I think you’re putting your finger on an important truth— that the way we relate to gender in modern society is broken, and leaves many young men feeling disenfranchised and alone. But I disagree very strongly with some of the conclusions you’ve come to about what the root of that problem is and what the solutions are. In particular, I find it incredibly disheartening that you went from having this amazing, gender-expansive experience personally, to concluding that transgender people (who have similar gender-expansive experiences, but on the scale of a lifetime) are fake or a part of what’s broken with gender in modern society. I wonder what you think about the leadership roles transgender people have played in indigenous communities (whose gender politics you seem to be very interested in) for thousands of years. Happy to link to more information on that if you are interested and don’t already know what I’m talking about.

I don’t think I can do the best job here in this comment at articulating what my problems are with your conclusions. In place of that, I would love to offer this video by one of my favorite YouTubers, which discusses (what I see as) the same problem you are identifying— the way men in modern western society have been left behind by current gender discourse, in a way that hurts everyone and deepens the gender divide: https://youtu.be/S1xxcKCGljY. Her take on the source of that problem and the solutions to it are different from yours (though perhaps not irreconcilable! With a few tweaks), and are more respectful of trans people. I would really honestly love to hear what you think of what she has to say. She has a very particular style of humor and argument that you’ll either love or hate, but either way I hope you’ll listen to what she has to say.

I really do respect the profound thinking you’ve been doing. It’s clear it is helping you heal, which is amazing to see. But I can’t help but worry that your healing may be coming at the price of promoting rhetoric that is harmful to people who are already suffering under the current status quo (I.e. transgender people). I hope you will read this comment, watch the video (and any other of the youtuber’s videos that catch your eye— I think her video on incel culture and the one on gender critical theory might also be relevant to the conversation) with an open mind, and let me know what you think about it.

Thanks for reading!

Ben

Expand full comment
Blueberry's avatar

Thank you for writing this. It matters

Expand full comment
35 more comments...

No posts